What’s in a name? The Airbnb reminder
Airbnb is creating renewed cause for a distinction between leases and licences to be considered by the courts
The distinction between leases and licences has long caused confusion and consternation for landowners, particularly in the context of a municipal council’s statutory obligations under the Local Government Act 1989 and, more recently, the Retail Leases Act 2003.
The new-age phenomenon of Airbnb has created renewed cause for this issue to be considered by the courts.
In Swan v Uecker , the Victorian Supreme Court recently found that a ‘licence’ granted by a landowner to AirBnB users in fact constituted a sub-lease. This decision has provided a timely reminder to landowners of the key distinguishing features between a lease and a licence, namely:
- a lease grants a tenant exclusive possession of a premises whereas a licence gives a licensee a non-exclusive contractual right to occupy the licensed area; and
- a lease gives the tenant a proprietary interest in the land which is capable of being assigned or transferred to a third party, whereas a licence does not give a licensee
- a proprietary interest in the land but a right personal to the licensee and enforceable in contract only.
When determining whether to grant a lease or licence, landowners should carefully consider the above principles.
The decision of Swan v Uecker has illustrated that - regardless of the title given to a document (i.e. a lease or a licence) - it is the nature of the rights granted to the occupant under the agreement that determine whether it is a lease or a licence.
Changes to the Unfair Contract Terms Regime. It’s here – Developers, are you ready?
The amendments to the laws governing UCT came into effect and apply to new contracts made at or after 9 November 2023
Section 9AB of the Sale of Land Act (Vic) – The Cost of Failing to Comply with Disclosure Obligations
The Supreme Court of Victoria confirmed authority to receive disclosures under section 9AB of the Sale of Land Act 1962
Victoria's Housing Statement: Exploring Challenges and Opportunities in the Decade Ahead
In response to the affordability issues confronting those that need to find a home, the Victoria’s Housing Statement.
Victorian Building System Review – Stage Two Report Published
We list the key factors cited by the Expert Panel as the basis for the proposed reform in Victoria.