Following the right road
Victorian Supreme Court decision highlights importance of adopting the right procedure when making a decision about the future of a road
A decision handed down by the Victorian Supreme Court on 27 July - Pulitano Pastoral Pty Ltd v Mansfield Shire Council – highlights the critical importance of adopting the right procedure when making a decision about the future of a road.
In that case, a decision to remove a road from a Road Register was successfully challenged on the ground that the Resolution did not demonstrate that the council had formed the requisite opinion under the Road Management Act 2004. The Resolution was also legally defective because of a failure to afford natural justice to the owner of land abutting the road.
Similarly, a subsequent decision to discontinue the road was quashed. This was because the Resolution initiating the procedure for discontinuance wrongly suggested that the council had already formed the opinion that the road was no longer reasonably required as a road.
Not every decision relating to a road will be as contentious. There are, however, valuable lessons about the procedure (and the form of Resolution necessary) that councils would do well to heed.
By Mark Hayes
Related articles
Looking out for smaller businesses – the revised rules for Commonwealth Procurement
By Anthony Willis, Patrick Collins
We explain the effect of recently enacted changes to the Commonwealth Procurement Rules, which commence on 1 July 2022.
Australian Contract Law: a recent case study – Sui v Jiang [2021] NSWCA 285
By Anthony Willis, Patrick Collins
Lost in translation: when the legal effect of a contract departs from its literal meaning...
Hope for flood victims? NSW Government announces the Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation
By Blake Dyer, Breellen Warry, Emily Dunford
We outline what you need to know about the newly established Northern Rivers Reconstruction Corporation (NRRC).
Recent News in FOI and Privacy
By Melanie Olynyk, Katy Zhu, Maryam Popal & Laura Dargan
Here is a snapshot of recent news in FOI and Privacy for Victorian government agencies....
Partner
Melbourne