When an objection is objectionable

In a decision handed down by Brown J on 20 May 2022 in Michaela Manicaros v Commercial Images (Aust) Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 83, the Queensland Supreme Court provided useful guidance on when a liquidator may recover their legal costs of a remuneration application from a creditor objecting to the application (Objector).
Her Honour indicated that generally, Courts should be hesitant to make costs orders against Objectors, as this might discourage them from legitimately raising concerns in remuneration applications. However, her Honour recognised that costs orders against Objectors could be made in exceptional circumstances and that such orders can be on a standard or indemnity basis.
The Court found that exceptional circumstances existed in this case for the Objector to pay the liquidator’s costs on a standard basis. This was because of the following:
- The Objector conducted himself as an adversary rather than as a mere objector in the application. This was because the Objector made unsubstantiated claims against the liquidator with no evidence filed to justify them.
- The Objector withdrew their opposition to the remuneration application well after the matter had been set down for hearing.
However, as the Objector’s conduct did not amount to serious and unjustifiable trouble and harassment and there was found to not have a predominant motivation which was for an ulterior purpose, the liquidators’ costs were not ordered to be paid on an indemnity basis.
Read more articles from the The Annual Return: 2022 in Review
Keep up to date with our legal insights and events
Sign upRecent articles

Understanding Australian Contract Law Through Evans v Air Canada
This case illustrates how important it is for contracts to be drafted clearly and comprehensively.

Navigating Privacy Reforms: Challenges and opportunities for government in 2025
This article covers key considerations for government agencies to ensure they are adapting to the changes.

Australia’s new merger notification regime is now “live”
Since 1 July 2025, the new merger notification regime can be used on a voluntary basis.
Partner
Melbourne